Forgotten Traits of the Church


August 14, 2012 by cbbeard

Author’s note:  This post is an edited reprint of my submission to a class discussion forum regarding effectiveness of the church universal.

The state of the church universal and its effectiveness is a mixed bag of excitement and disappointment, successes and failures, growth and decline.  Some reports show that Christianity as a whole is thriving, and in some areas of the world that is true.  Statistics by the Pew Research Center show that Christianity in Sub-Saharan Africa grew from approximately 8.5 million in 1910 (9.1% of the population) to approximately 516.5 million in 2010 (62.7% of the population).  Christianity in the “Global South” overall has grown from 9.2% of the population to 23.5% of the population from 1910-2010 (Pew Research Center, 2011).

On the other hand, Christianity in the “Global North” has not fared so well.  While 86.7% of the population were Christians in 1910, only 69% of the population were Christian in 2010 (Pew Research Center, 2011).

The United States reflects this decline. Krejcir reported that census figures show a 9.5% decline in membership of Protestant churches between 1990 and 2000!  He also found that when “frequent attendance” is defined by attending church at least twice a month, the statistics in the United States are as follows:

  • 22% of Americans “frequently” attended church in 1992
  • 20.5% of Americans “frequently” attended church in 1995
  • 19% of Americans “frequently” attended church in 1999
  • 18.0% of Americans “frequently” attended in church in 2002

Today we will focus on the Western church, as it is clearly in decline as a whole.  While there are different contributing factors for the decline of individual congregations, I believe that two main “culprits” responsible for the decline of the Western church are focus and leadership.


When the church was born in Acts 2, the church was clearly focused on serving Jesus.  The church adhered to Christ’s teachings of loving God and loving others, and did so even at the expense of their own physical peril.  The results are seen in Acts 2:42-47:

They devoted themselves to the apostles’ teaching and to fellowship, to the breaking of bread and to prayer. Everyone was filled with awe at the many wonders and signs performed by the apostles. All the believers were together and had everything in common. They sold property and possessions to give to anyone who had need. Every day they continued to meet together in the temple courts. They broke bread in their homes and ate together with glad and sincere hearts, praising God and enjoying the favor of all the people. And the Lord added to their number daily those who were being saved.

Somewhere along the way, however, the church’s focus shifted from Jesus to the church.  Jesus was certainly present, but no longer was the church “out and about” as described in Acts 2.  The church now had a building.  It had programs and events.  It now had paid staff.  So the focus was less on Jesus and more on the church.  Instead of spreading CHRISTianity, the church was winning people to what Reggie McNeal called CHURCHianity (emphasis mine).  McNeal wrote:

In North America the invitation to become a Christian has become largely an invitation to convert to the church. The assumption is that anyone serious about being a Christian will order their lives around the church, shift their life and work rhythms around the church schedule, channel their charitable giving through the church, and serve in some church ministry; in other words, serve the church and become a fervent marketer to bring others into the church to do the same. (McNeal, 2003, p. 11)

Therefore, the church has become centralized and institutional.  People are taken out of the context of their lives and placed in the isolation of the church building.  Instead of being in the temple courts (which is NOT equivalent to a church building by the way) and in their homes and neighborhoods as in Acts 2, the church was now hanging out in the building doing fellowship dinners and Bible studies.  People started going to church instead of being the church.


There are two ways in which the Western church’s approach to leadership has contributed to decline.

First, leadership, like the structure of the church itself, has become centralized.  The hiring of staff has allowed the church to delegate ministry to those staff. With hired staff, people started to think, “It is the preacher’s job to study and teach.  It is the minister’s job to evangelize.  It is the pastor who is supposed to be visiting the hospitals and praying for people.  It’s even the staff’s job to come up with ministry opportunities.”  As McNeal wrote, “Every time I see the slogan “every member a minister” I cringe. It usually means that there has been a lot of effort put into getting church members to get church work done” (p. 45)

Secondly, leadership in the church has neglected the full scope of God’s intentions.  Hirsch and Catchim identified the problem as a focus on the “shepherd and teacher” aspect of ministry.  Most paid ministers and key leaders such as elders have been focused on these aspects of ministry.  However, Hirsch and Catchim suggest that Ephesians 4 is prescriptive for the church and that the church should have leaders who are gifted in one of the fivefold areas of ministry: apostle, prophet, evangelist, shepherd, and teacher.  Each one of these areas should be present in the church if it is to reach its God-intended potential.  Though a full discussion of these roles will be reserved for another post, it is the apostle, prophet, and evangelist roles that must be present for maintaining the ultimate mission of “sentness” and renewal of the church.

Moving forward, the church must become the movement God intended it to be.  This will require a great deal of “unfreezing” of the underlying assumptions about church that are wrong.  We must decentralize the structure and ministry of the church and release people to be the church where they exist each and every day.  Our people already exist in a cross-cultural and diverse environment as a whole.  If they simply live with Jesus as their focus and obey the word of God; and if they partner with other believers, the church will reflect that diverse environment. These shifts require us not to use new theories, but require us to return to the ancient example and instruction for the church.

So what do you think?  Why is the Western church (and American church in particular) in decline?  What do you think we need to do as a church?

Hirsch, A., Catchim, T., & Breen, M. (2012). The permanent revolution:Apostolic imagination and practice for the 21st century church (1st ed.). San Fransisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.
McNeal, R. (2003). The present future: Six tough questions for the church (1st ed.). San    Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.
Krejcir, R.J. (2007). Statistics and Reasons for Church Decline. Schaeffer Institute.  Retrievedfrom:
Pew Research Center, (2011). Global Christianity:A Report on the Size and Distribution of the World’s Christian Population. Retrieved from
Schein, E.H. (2010). Organizational culture and leadership (4th ed.). San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass

8 thoughts on “Forgotten Traits of the Church

  1. Peggy says:

    “People started going to church instead of being the church.” I think you hit the nail on the head here. We have been too concerned with what happens in the two hours on Sunday morning instead of “being the body” all day, every day! Now, how to change that? Not so sure. I believe we are moving in the right direction at CCC but I don’t think we are near there yet! Not even close! Sunday morning is important and needed, but our focus must change…..actually, MY focus must change. I look around and I don’t know many non Christians! Most of my co-workers, my neighbors, my contacts on a daily basis know Christ and live some sort of Christian life. I haven’t quite figured out how to “meet” non Christians. Working on it, and praying hard and if you continue these types of blogs, I will have to eventually act on it! Thanks!

    • cbbeard says:

      Great thoughts Peggy! This is one of those “easier said than done” deals for sure. For me it requires a lot of “unfreezing” of my old habits and ideas, and that is rarely a fun process.

      Thanks so much for posting.

  2. says:

    Chris from a leadership point of view:

    Church leaders could benefit from motivating and empowering congregations to “go forward and preach the gospel.” (Mark 16:15). Daft (2008) defines empowerment as the delegation of power and/or authority to others. Church leaders need to “create the environment” that supports/cultivates/rewards congregants to be motivated to take a more active role in ministry. The 12 disciples is one example of empowerment (shared authority and power) that resulted in the birth of the preaching of the NT Gospel. I assert the view that Jesus was the empowering leader who appealed to the disciples need for achievement, affiliation, and power (authority over others) which intrinsically motivated them to the best they could be. Thus achieving the desired outcomes envisioned by the leader.

    Bottom line: Ministers need to use their leadership power to empower and motivate others to accomplish the Great Commission. Get everybody involved and don’t delegate to paid staffers the responsibility that belongs to all of us!

    If I rambled too much here; feel free to delete!

    Thanks, Chris. I look forward to more blogs.

    Daft, R.L. (2008). The leadership experience (5th ed.). Mason, OH: South-Western CENGAGE

    • Posted by Jason Britt says:

      Posted by Jason Britt.”.

    • cbbeard says:

      Right on, Jason!

      Part of what you are talking about is decentralization, and that’s another post as well! The key is helping people realize what they are capable of with the power of the Holy Spirit in their lives. I think most of us don’t even realize what we are capable of, or what God can do through us.

      So I guess empowerment comes both from leadership, as well as understanding true empowerment comes from God…and is expected by him!

      Thanks for your thoughts

  3. Jamie Goebel says:

    One of the things I have realized as we have studied this past couple of years under your leadership, is that Jesus has gotten left out of Christianity. If we truly follow Jesus and his example, it is so much easier to reach people. It is easier to explain God’s love and his will. It gets really hard to convert someone if you begin with your version of Christianity, be it Church of Christ, Baptist, Catholic, etc….Most pre-believers couldn’t care less what we do at our church as opposed to what they do at another. It is all the same…dos and don’ts. But if they see how Christ changes how we react in stressful situations, or how we handle a rude customer (or teenager in my case), or treat our spouse….it makes it real. If they hear that they are loved by their creator and can see what that love is willing to do through His people, then they might be willing to check out what those people do on Sundays as well. I look forward to reading more of your thoughts.

    • cbbeard says:

      Re: If they hear that they are loved by their creator and can see what that love is willing to do through His people, then they might be willing to check out what those people do on Sundays as well.

      I really like this! I think a key part of being God’s people (aka “the church”) and fulfilling our mission is to to be a tangible example of who God is and what he has done and is offering.

      Thanks so much for the comment!

  4. […] and steep statistical decline is evidence of that (check out my earlier post for more on this HERE).  Therefore, if we are to be the church God intended, not only making better disciples, but also […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: